REVIEW: Shapen Coco Mary Janes – A Little Chanel, A Lot More Barefoot
I finally got my hands on my holy-grail ballet flats. Elegant shoes that don’t squeeze your toes into an unnatural shape can be difficult to find. Thankfully, Shapen, one of the prominent purveyors of classy barefoot shoes, has us covered.
Does it deliver on barefoot fundamentals while still looking luxurious? I’ll cover fit, materials and practicality to see whether it’s worth the price tag in my Shapen Coco review below.
Ad/Affiliate Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through one of these links, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you. This doesn’t influence my opinions or reviews. I also link to brands and retailers without any affiliate arrangement.
Not measured, reported as 5.5mm stack height without optional insole.
Five Toes Free Shoe Profile
TOE BOX
Tapered
0
Foot-shaped
FLEXIBILITY
Stiff
0
Very flexible
GROUND FEEL
Muted
0
Very direct
WEIGHT
Heavy
0
Very light
GRIP
Minimal
0
Aggressive
WEATHER PROTECTION
Low
0
Resistant
BREATHABILITY
Low
0
Very High
The verdict
Fantastic style and quality. The gorgeous patent leather combined with the wide belt over the foot sets them apart. Despite the initially stiff upper, they broke in surprisingly quickly. The sole is flexible, toe-box wide, ground feel is reasonable, and the adjustable strap makes for a secure fit.
First Impressions
These were a stand-out model when they were first released last year thanks to their glossy leather and chunky buckle detail. I’ve been coveting them ever since and finally caved.
They look as good in real life as they do in the product photos. The patent leather is pristine. They are lightweight and surprisingly spacious. The deep ruby red is glorious in all lighting. They come in a patent black leather too, which is just as gorgeous.
You can buy these direct from Shapen, a Slovakian brand, which shouldn’t be an issue considering they are under the £135 threshold for customs duty. Note that Shapen don’t accept returns from the UK, so be sure to double check sizing and reviews on fit to see if they suit. There are also UK retailers that stock the shoe, should you be unsure if they’re for you.
Fit & Sizing
For my 27cm long foot I got a size EU 42. Shapen’s size chart lists this as being 27.6cm long internally. I measure on my plus12 a few mm shorter at 27.4cm. Perhaps they will stretch very slightly, but they are just ok for me in terms of length. You can get away with 5mm or so extra room in ballet flats, but I would have benefitted from them being very slightly longer. The EU 43 is listed as 28.3cm, which would have been too long in this style.
The toe box is moderately wide and foot-shaped, making it better suited to Egyptian and Greek foot shapes. There is adequate space for my own moderately wide Egyptian toe profile. Because they are secured to the foot with a strap, they may also work with narrower widths too, provided they use the supplied insole.
That said, the strap is great at keeping the shoe secure on the foot, so length sizing is less temperamental. The buckle is adjustable, which is particularly useful if you’re wanting to wear them both with and without socks. I find for me they fit best with thinner socks, as in nylon style, rather than thicker cotton blend ones.
They’re not exactly slip-ons. The buckle has an elasticated portion where it attaches, making it possible to stretch it a bit to wiggle your foot in. It still takes me a bit of force to do so, especially if wearing socks, but it’s tolerable. Loosening them an extra step via the buckle to make them easier to get on makes them too roomy.
Because of the adjustability of the buckle and the optional insole that they come with, they would fit a range of foot volumes. My low-to-mid volume feet fit perfectly at the middle buckle hole, without using the insole. Lower volume would likely need the insole. Higher volume have plenty of room to loosen, but may struggle with the leather at the front of the foot potentially digging in.
The patent leather is sturdy and I was initially worried about the stiff leather digging in around the ankle area. I wore them around the house with socks for a couple of hours and they were already forming to me feet! After wearing them outdoors on longer walks, I’ve had no issues with discomfort or rubbing. They won’t offer the same forgiving fit as a knitted upper or stretchy barefoot trainer, but that’s not their intended purpose.
Design & Construction
The patent leather is a nice choice, as there are few similar barefoot options. Strappy barefoot Mary Janes exist, but not with patent leather combined with the wide statement belt strap. They stand out as a bit more edgy and fashion-forward than their more twee looking counterparts. They pair really nicely with wide leg trousers, as well as nice socks, and of course dresses and skirts.
The leather naturally creases just behind the forefoot, but the shoes are still looking good so far. It will be interesting to see whether they keep up their pristine appearance. Patent leather needs to be looked after slightly differently to normal leather – using standard conditioners on them can cloud the glossy coating. You also need to avoid storing them pressed together for long periods, as the surfaces can stick and potentially damage the coating.
The sole of the Shapen Coco is fairly grippy for a dressy barefoot shoe. They grip well on rainy pavements and grass; they have 2mm deep lugs. The sole design is also well thought out: the wrapping of it around the shoe gives it a chunkier look, complementing the wide buckle strap. Despite its appearance, the sole doesn’t feel particularly chunky. The shoe remains very flexible, and ground feel is reasonably good (note that I wear them without the optional insole).
The stiffness of the leather upper is more of a barrier to flexibility than the sole – plus the fact I don’t want to roll them tight to further crease the patent leather unnecessarily! Despite that, they broke in on my first day of wearing them. I would recommend to do so in thin socks first, so you don’t risk your foot skin should you find they initially dig a bit.
They have a “Microline” lining that Shapen states is “100% breathable”. However, patent leather has a coating that makes is less breathable than non-patent leather, so I’m not convinced this tells us much about breathability of the shoes as a whole. I haven’t worked up a sweat in these yet, so can’t comment on breathability. It would be nice if there was more transparency regarding what Microline actually is – I suspect it’s plastic in the form of a synthetic microfibre fabric, although Shapen doesn’t provide enough detail to confirm this.
Usage & Final Thoughts
These are, in my opinion, the coolest barefoot Mary jane style shoes on the market. Shapen have really cornered the market on fancy, fashionable and elevated flats.
Their adjustability makes them suitable for a relatively wide range of foot volumes.
These are fairly wide in the toes, with some tapering on the outer edge that is typical for Shapen.
Patent leather (while stiffer, less breathable, and a bit more temperamental than other leathers) really looks great and adds to the eye catching look.
They’re substantial enough to wear with socks in cooler weather, making them ideal for the shoulder seasons and milder winter days.
Other people report they are, however I found them a couple of mm shorter than advertised via my Plus12 measurement device. There will always be some variability in manufacturing, so it’s difficult to say whether they come up short across the board. Double check the Shapen size chart and potentially consider sizing up if you want to wear with socks or are worried they will be too short.
Can you wear Shapen Coco Mary Janes with socks?
Yes. If you need to make more space to accommodate socks, don’t use the insole and potentially loosen the buckle.
Are Shapen Coco shoes made from real leather?
Yes – it’s real patent leather. Patent leather is just leather with a special coating to give it its characteristic glossy look. The Shapen Coco is not suitable for vegans.
Do Shapen Coco shoes crease?
Yes, patent leather develops creases with wear. This is most noticeable around the forefoot where the shoe bends. You can only see minor creasing in some photos in this review, as they haven’t yet been heavily worn for more than a season.
What other classy Barefoot options are there?
Shapen have a lot of nice options, including wedding suitable shoes. The Shapen Orchid is one of the most ‘black tie’ appropriate barefoot shoes available. The Shapen Poppy is a classy sandal with an ankle strap. The Shapen Lily is a leather peep-toe sandal. The Shapen Tulip is a more classic ballet flat. There are plenty more models on their website!
Be Lenka (who accept UK returns AND you won’t pay customs duty even if your order is >£135) also have some really elevated styles in this category, including the gorgeous royal blue Be Lenka Lilea and the classic Mary Jane style Be Lenka Amalea