Vivobarefoot Tracker AT II Review – Is it a Good Barefoot Hiking Boot?

The tracker and its many iterations form one of the primary Vivobarefoot boot lines. This review is of the Vivobarefoot Tracker AT II, see my thoughts on this all-rounder below! To decode the model name: AT stands for ‘all terrain’ – i.e., suitable for both slippery mud and firmer ground. The II is because it’s a 2nd generation iteration.

Learn about the differences between the tracker models below in the FAQ at the end of the review.

Quick Summary:

New to Barefoot Shoes? See beginner resources below:

Skip all the reading: 3 Step Barefoot Shoe Quick Start Guide.

What is a barefoot shoe and what are the benefits of wearing them?

In-depth guide to getting the perfect shoe for your foot.

Barefoot brand directory. Listings and info on retailers.

First Impressions

vivobarefoot tracker AT II review boots

I was lucky to get these on sale, the usual price is £200 without any discounts applied (there are often discounts available!). I managed to nab the women’s and men’s in the same size for comparison. Vivobarefoot have a generous and easy returns policy, so trying at home is simple.

Why did I order both the men’s and women’s? Some barefoot brands like Vivo and Xero have differing fits in men’s versus women’s styles. Sometimes the shoes are identical except for slight differences in width and shape – this is the case with this model. Which one you should order is really dependant on your foot dimensions – if you like more toe space you may prefer the men’s, like me. If you have both narrow feet and toes, the women’s may be more suitable, as they are narrower throughout.

Anyway, the boots are gorgeous, as you can see. They look rugged expensive with their attention to detail, embossed logos, lugged sole, and heavy duty leather. These are the Bracken in men’s size EU 43 (UK 9), which is a lovely warm brown with a natural colour variation in the leather.

Fit & Sizing

vivobarefoot tracker AT II review sole resized

They are comfortable right out of the box. Lacing up was quick and easy due to the smooth-gliding metal eyelet loops and the speed hooks at the ankle. The men’s are higher volume around the ankle area, so I have to cinch them to fit snug.

I love the balance of how heavy duty they are versus being lightweight: the padding isn’t restrictive and the quality of the leather means they are still hard-wearing. Likewise the sole is perfect for most terrains due to the grippy lugs and ‘bumper’ like moulding around the boot. There is still a decent amount of ground feel and flexibility for a hiking boot, but of course it isn’t comparable to a light weight more minimalist style for everyday urban wear.

As mentioned, the toe box in the men’s is not particularly narrow, it’s a moderate width. The toe box shape has some sloping on the outer edge, meaning they’re more suited to Egyptian or Greek shaped toe profiles. People with square-shaped toe profiles of particularly wide toe areas may find their toes restricted.

My 27cm long, Egyptian shaped, moderate volume feet fit into the men’s EU 43 comfortably with enough room for moderately thick socks.

Design & Construction

vivobarefoot tracker AT II review interior

These look cool enough that I want to be able to wear them around town, but they are too rugged looking for some of my outfits! I do incorporate them when I can casually and they get plenty of outings when I go to the woods or on longer hikes. The colour and texture variations keep them looking interesting for a single-colour and single-material upper.

The materials are premium – they use the Vivobarefoot ‘wild hide’ leather, which is thick and hard-wearing. The interior is part leather around the top section and cotton around the foot itself. The texture and colour variations of the design mean even if they get beaten-up they will still look nice.

There are some really nice design features: there is a cut-out just above the Achilles heel area. This hugely improves their comfort around the ankle when walking, there is no ‘tug’ due to having a boot tightened around your ankle. The tongue is gusseted, handy for keeping out the wet, gravel and anything else you don’t want inside your boot. The sole is well thought-out with textured, flat bottomed lugs. It’s neatly stitched to the upper and is moulded around the boot – good for helping prevent too much water ingress on wet ground.

One important thing to note is that there is no waterproof membrane. This means they are water resistant (due to the naturally water resistant properties of the leather) at best, not waterproof. The upside is that they are more breathable due to the lack of membrane, stretching their use to warmer weather too.

Usage & Final Thoughts

vivobarefoot tracker AT II review shoe

They are well-equipped for ‘all terrain’ as advertised, except perhaps the wettest conditions. I wouldn’t be wading in them, but they can comfortably take rain and mud. Grip is decent, even on slicker mud.

They are really an all-rounder for weather too: while too warm for the hottest days of a UK summer, they are adaptive to most seasons due to their mid-level of insulation, removable thermal insole, and breathability. In winter they can be combined with wool socks to be toasty. For people in more freezing climates, you might want to look at more specialist cold-weather boots. Click here for an article on how to find the winter boot for your climate.

If you are in the market for a luxurious hiking boot that is also incredibly functional, this model is ideal. The build quality and materials mean the boot will last years, especially if you take care of the leather. I have kept mine as they meet all my requirements for a comfy barefoot hiking boot.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Vivobarefoot Tracker AT II better than the other Tracker boots / Which Vivobarefoot Tracker is the Best?

There are LOTS of iterations of the tracker. At the time of writing, these models are currently being sold new by Vivobarefoot:

That’s not including the discontinued models, such as the original trackers in the ‘FG’ (firm ground) and ‘SG’ (soft ground) versions. Some models incorporated a waterproof membrane. The Tracker AT II does away with the membrane. It’s not ‘better’ or ‘worse’, just different: now water resistance is decreased, but breathability increased. Which model is best for you depends on your intended use and preferences.

Is the Tracker AT II suitable for winter hiking?

Yes, in relatively mild UK winters, especially when the thermal insole is worn. You can wear thermal / wool socks for increased warmth. This isn’t advertised as a ‘winter boot’ and the leather upper means it’s rather breathable, but it would certainly be warm enough for less extreme winter conditions and temperatures.

Is the Tracker AT II suitable for Summer hiking?

Outside of particularly warm conditions, yes. It’s not a specific summer hiking boot, it’s a substantial leather boot that covers the ankle. The plus side for summer is that the insole is removable and the boot is relatively breathable. If you want something cooler for hot weather, there are other models provided by Vivobarefoot or other retailers, If you need proper hiking boots for summer, it will do, but there are less warm options available from Vivobarefoot or other brands. Like the Vivobarefoot Jungle Esc boot (built for jungles!) or the Freet Kidepo.

Does the Tracker AT II have a wide toe box?

It’s wide enough to firmly be classified as a barefoot shoe, but not the widest. It’s very dependant on your foot shape, due to the sloping of the outside of the shoe. It will work better for Egyptian or Greek shaped feet, rather than those with blocky, square toe profiles.

If you need more width, go with the men’s version. If you have narrow toes and don’t like the extra space, go with the women’s. Design wise they are identical, just slightly differing fit in terms of width.

Is the Tracker AT II actually waterproof?

No, the upper is not waterproof. There is no waterproof membrane and leather is only somewhat water resistant. The sole is bonded and quite weather resistant and the tongue is gusseted, so they will be fine in wet conditions still. They would not be suitable for being submerged. You could potentially treat them with a water repellent leather treatment to increase resistance (potentially at the expense of breathability).

If you want an all-rounder hiking boot more resistant to water you can try to find the older Tracker boots with the membrane or try another model or brand. You will struggle to find a truly waterproof boot that isn’t a rubber rainboot / wellington, but clever construction and membranes can make a shoe near enough waterproof. The Vivobarefoot Tracker Winter III SG is listed as waterproof.

Is the Vivobarefoot Tracker AT II worth the price?

At £200 it’s dependant on what you want from a hiking boot. This boot will get a lot of use if you hike year-round in moderate temperatures and it is built well enough to last. If your budget allows and you’re in the market for a genuinely functional and comfy barefoot hiking boot, this is ideal. If you need something specific to more extreme weather conditions, need something lower cost, or something that can stand up to a lot of water, there are better alternatives. Keep in mind no boot can do everything well. Cheaper used options are sometimes available on 2nd hand marketplaces and on Revivo (Vivobarefoot’s own used shoe refurbishing business).

Is the Tracker AT II suitable for everyday wear?

If it fits your aesthetic, why not! They are comfortable enough to be worn around town, but I personally prefer something less substantial for everyday wear running errands. They are more usable on concrete than the ‘SG’ (soft ground) tracker models, where the concern is wearing down the softer rubber sole and spikier lugs prematurely. They are not “work suitable”, unless you work outdoors – in which case perhaps they are an excellent work option for someone working as a gardener or similar outdoor roles.

Scroll to Top